When it comes to homeownership costs, insurance premiums are one area where many people overlook the potential for savings. One of the most effective ways to reduce your home insurance bill is by installing a new roof. Insurance providers often view a new roof as a major risk reducer, which can translate to significant discounts. But before you count on lower premiums, it’s important to understand the nuances of how and when a new roof actually affects your home insurance.
Why Insurance Companies Care About Your Roof
Your roof is your home’s first line of defense against the elements. Wind, hail, rain, and snow all put stress on your roofing system. An old, damaged, or outdated roof significantly increases the likelihood of a claim. Insurance companies know this, which is why the condition, age, and materials of your roof play a large role in your premium calculation.

A new roof reduces the risk of weather-related damage, water leaks, mold, and structural deterioration. It signals to your insurer that your home is better protected, and that they are less likely to have to pay out a costly claim.
How Much Can You Save?
The exact savings vary depending on your insurer and location, but homeowners can typically expect to save anywhere from 5% to 35% on their premiums with a new roof. Roofs made of impact-resistant materials or designed to withstand specific regional hazards (like hurricanes or wildfires) may qualify for even greater discounts.
It’s also worth noting that many insurers offer additional discounts for upgrades like:
- Wind mitigation features
- Class 4 impact-resistant shingles
- Fire-resistant materials
- Modern roof ventilation systems
When a New Roof Might NOT Lower Your Insurance
While a new roof often helps, there are situations where it may not result in savings:
1. Your Insurer Doesn’t Offer Roof Discounts
Not all insurance providers offer discounts for new roofs. Some may include the roof condition in their base pricing model but not reward you explicitly for upgrading.
2. Ineligible Roofing Materials
If you install a roof with materials not approved or rated by your insurer (like certain wood shakes or untested synthetics), you might not qualify for a discount. In fact, it could raise your premium.
3. Incomplete Documentation
To qualify for savings, you often need to provide documentation like the installation invoice, roofing permits, and details about the materials used. Without this, your insurer might not update your policy.
4. Lack of Additional Protective Features
Some insurers only offer discounts if the new roof includes specific upgrades like hurricane straps or underlayment barriers. Simply replacing old shingles with new ones may not be enough.

Tips to Maximize Insurance Savings
- Talk to Your Insurer First: Before replacing your roof, ask your insurance agent what materials and features qualify for discounts.
- Use Certified Contractors: Always hire licensed, insured roofing professionals who follow building codes and can provide the right documentation.
- Consider Impact-Resistant Shingles: Investing a bit more in high-grade materials can lead to higher long-term savings.
- Request a Re-Inspection: Once the roof is installed, ask your insurer for a home inspection to reassess your premiums.
Final Thoughts
A new roof can be a smart investment for your home’s protection and your wallet. While it doesn’t guarantee lower insurance premiums in every situation, choosing the right materials, documenting your upgrade, and working closely with your insurer can greatly improve your chances of securing a discount. Beyond insurance savings, a new roof also adds to your home’s value, curb appeal, and energy efficiency—making it a win all around.
For expert roofing installation using insurance-approved materials, trust Brown’s Roofing—your partner in protection and peace of mind.